10 Things To Know Before Buying Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter

One of the most popular grocery store items from Trader Joe’s is cookie butter. These cookie butter mixes are very different from other cookie butter mixes, but they tend to be on the higher end of the spectrum.

Here are a few things you need to know about cookie butter, as it is one of the best things in Trader Joe’s and it’s also one of the best spreads to have on hand.

10 Things To Know Before Buying Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter In 2022

1. Customers Say Trader Joe’s Has Really Good Cookie Butter

An Amazon customer reviews the product and comments about the best invention ever. This is the best product ever.

My husband and I like to eat the jam right from the can. We open the can and add a bit of juice to the jar, then eat it out of the jar.

2. Trader Joe’s Does Not Make Its Own Cookie Butter

When it comes to the food that Trader Joe’s sells, it does not all originate in Trader Joe’s factories. In fact, it doesn’t even originate in Trader Joe’s stores.

It gets most of its materials from other well-known manufacturers.

3. You Don’t Need to Keep Your Cookie Butter From Trader Joe’s in the Refrigerator

It says that you should not refrigerate it after opening the jar. It is because of the freshness of the product.

Different ingredients in the cookie butter may change the texture of it when chilled, like palm oil and coconut oil. If it’s too hard to eat, refrigerate it.

4. Trader Joe’s Had Different Flavors of Cookie Butter

The Trader Joe’s butter cookie flavor.
The Trader Joe’s butter cookie flavor with honey.
The Trader Joe’s oatmeal cookie butter.

In the recent years, this flavor was discontinued. It is likely that the flavor will not be re-released because it is discontinued.

5. Cookie Butter From Trader Joe’s Is Not Vegan Friendly

The cookie butter uses dairy-derived butter flavoring, which doesn’t necessarily mean there are any animal products used in the product.

We’ve found at least one Trader Joe’s that contains tree nuts, milk, and eggs. Our best guess is that they are located in the Northeast.

So, this vegan chorizo would not be healthy for people with an allergy or an aversion to nuts.

6. Cookie Butter From Trader Joe’s Isn’t Gluten-Free

Trader Joe’s cookie butter uses wheat flour, which is not safe for those who are gluten-free.

The protein is also high in the seeds, which can be detrimental for those with celiac disease or anyone with an allergy to nuts.

7. Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Is Not Exactly Healthy

There may be something wrong with the cookie butter. The cookie butter needs to be good for you, or it is not good for your belly.

While the cookie butter doesn’t contain any vitamins or minerals, it does contain some calories.

The sandwich contains lots of carbs and fats, two things that are bad for your heart!

8. There Are Lots of Ways to Eat Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter

When you have this jar in the cupboard, you can get creative! You can use cookie butter on toast, add it to your smoothies, or use it in baking. The possibilities are endless!

Cookies and peanut butter is one of the best snacks, but, I think, cookie butter would be even better.

In order to give you the best nutrition, you may want to snack on some cookie butter with apple slices.

There are plenty of other ways you can enjoy Trader Joe’s cookie butter, it tastes pretty good spread on toast.

We can make waffles on a Saturday morning for the whole family to enjoy.

You can also use butter or shortening mixed with white or yellow icing for a frosting and place on a cake.

9. Other Cookie Butter Products You Can Find at Trader Joe’s

Trader Joe’s cookies and ice cream are the best, and Speculoos Cookie Butter Ice Cream is the best Speculoos Cookie.

The Ice Cream Truck has a flavor called Cookie Butter. There’s cookie butter swirls in the vanilla ice cream.

Another is Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Sandwich Cookies, the flavor is fantastic and it’s a great option for breakfast or dessert.

Also the Trader Joe’s cookie butter beer is a fun flavor. It’s made with Speculoos beer. They’re not really meant to drink, but people end up drinking it.

The butterbeer you are describing sounds a lot like the Imperial Stout, which is also a beer that is made with cookie butter. The cookie butter does a lot to add depth to that stout, and it has a strong vanilla flavor.

Cookie butter ice cream isn’t your average dessert! They are actually made from real cookies! These cookies are made with shortening and have no corn syrup added. They have a creamy texture that is perfect for scooping.

Since the ingredients for this cake are frozen, I would recommend you to bake it in the oven for one hour. If you do that, you may notice that the cheesecake is frozen, it will not be creamy and soft, but the taste will be superb.

Although they are not available now, this product was also delicious. It is also quite popular, so don’t worry about finding it in your area.

10. Other Stores Have Cookie Butter

If you are wondering where to get cookie butter from other stores, you may be able to get it from your neighborhood grocery store or even online.

Even though Trader Joe’s brand of peanut butter is pretty expensive, you should be able to find it cheaper online.

Want to learn more about the products Trader Joe’s sells, like cheese and dips? You can also check out our blog post on the things to know before buying Trader Joe’s cheese and dips.


Trader Joe’s products are often not only used to make traditional recipes but also to make healthy alternative recipes, like these pumpkin cookies.

The best way to enjoy this amazing cheese is to put it on bread and enjoy it in a sandwich with sliced tomatoes. But, if you want to dip it in apple slices, you won’t be disappointed with this cheese.

Similar Posts:

About the author

I have always been a shopaholic. A lot of times my questions went unanswered when it came to retail questions, so I started Talk Radio News. - Caitlyn Johnson

Leave a Comment