Understanding The Timberline Pewter Gray Vs. Charcoal Comparison

Choosing paint for your roofs and walls can be confusing; every color has its characteristic look and feel. A slight change in color shade can make a significant difference.

Pewter gray and charcoal are great options for painting roofs and walls. They come in various shades. With the right combination, pewter gray and charcoal can give your room an exotic feel.

However, when you put these colors head to head, making a particular choice can be tricky. Therefore, a comprehensive comparison would come in handy.

Timberline Pewter Gray Vs. Charcoal

The difference between pewter gray and charcoal is in their shade. Pewter gray has a lighter shade than charcoal, which runs from dark gray to almost black.

Many people prefer pewter gray for their roof because it produces a brilliant appearance against sunlight. In addition, the pewter gray roof appears to have a glossy surface when the sun shines on it. The result is a classy and exotic look.

However, if you’re not keen on artistic effects, a charcoal roof also has its advantages. Because charcoal is darker, charcoal roofs hide dirt easily and absorb it. So, if you want your roof to retain heat, charcoal is what you need.

Now, choosing color shades for your room is a different ball game. Pewter gray is a better choice for your room walls than charcoal. Using charcoal gray paint in your room can make it appear smaller and enclosed. However, this effect will not be so severe with a lighter floor.

Lighter color shades like pewter gray are always best for room painting. Pewter gray is a cool, soft, dull, and balanced color. It often gives off the feeling of depth, warmth, and a sense of confidence.

On the other hand, dark charcoal gray gives off the feeling of strength. It communicates dignity, formality, weight, and solemnity. Sometimes, it can give off an eerie feeling, especially when the room has low lighting and dark floors.

Your choice will depend on your preferences, values, the building, and the amount of sunlight that gets into the building.

We’ve said that pewter and charcoal come in different shades. So, how do you choose a shade that fits your project?

How To Choose Pewter Or Charcoal Color Shade

As beautiful as pewter and charcoal colors may be, they can be misleading if you don’t check them properly, decking your roof or walls with them. To choose a color that fits, first get a sample of the paint you wish to use.

Paint the color in a white space and oversee the painting throughout the day. Notice how the sun’s rays affect color. If you find the effect pleasing, you can settle for it.

This test is essential because it helps you avoid mistakes. There’s nothing as annoying as feeling like you made a wrong choice. Apart from the lack of satisfaction, it’s a waste of money since you got no value for it.

This test also allows room for trial and error. You can try the test as many times as possible until you get the right color that fits every space. Of course, you’ll also get the perfect color for your look.

If you’re having difficulty deciding on what color, then it’s time to consider the Light Reflective Value (LRV).

The LRV of color ranges from 0-100. 0 shows that the color is dark, while 100 indicates it is light. So, if your house receives less sunlight, go for colors closer to the number 100. But, if your home has enough sunlight, go for colors closer to number 0.

Charcoal may be closer to 0 and should be perfect for a room with enough sunlight. But is charcoal black?

Difference Between Charcoal Black And Black

Charcoal black is very dark, but it is not black. The significant difference is that black is black and does not have a duplicate.

Charcoal black is a ‘shade of black,’ but it’s not the black color itself. Shades of black are colors that take their background from black and only slightly differ from black. So, charcoal is a variation of black. It has a low lightness, unlike black.

Next, we look at the best charcoal grey colors for painting. Finally, if you’re looking for something for your project, you can look at some of the options below.

Charcoal Gray Colors Best For Painting

Kendall charcoal:

This neutral color paint is dark gray paint, with yellow and green undertones. The undertones are responsible for this paint’s “earthy” look.

You can blend the Kendall charcoal with crisp or creamy white to bring out its beauty.

Wolf gray:

This gray paint has a blue undertone. The Wolf gray is perfect with crisp white color. This gray is Benjamin Moore’s wolf gray.

Englewood Cliff:

This has a slight hint of a blue undertone, unlike wolf gray. It is a medium-toned charcoal paint and it will make a house with adequate natural light lovely.


This is the darkest color on the list. It’s almost black, but it’s not. The Peppercorn is a deep charcoal and is best in a room with a generous amount of sunlight.

Web gray:

This is the lighter version of Peppercorn, but just a little bit. It has a navy blue undertone.

Summit gray:

This dark charcoal paint has a taupe undertone. It’s best to blend it with a creamy or yellow tint, primarily because of its creamy undertone.

Pike’s peak:

This is a lighter and more beautiful version. It has a blue undertone. It looks like you’re writing with blue on charcoal. It’s the steely blue paint color and is best for houses with low sunlight.

Arctic seal:

It’s similar to Peppercorn, with only a slight difference in lightness. It’s a Benjamin Moore’s deep, dark charcoal.

If your house receives little sunlight and needs to use either Peppercorn or arctic paint, go for the arctic. It’ll give you the darkness you want but with a touch of lightness.

Pewter Gray Colors Best For Painting

Dark pewter:

This is the darkest shade on the list. It’s a deep gray hue with blue undertones. It’s beautiful, dark, and moody.

Revere pewter:

This is a brighter shade and one of the most popular. Interior decorators recommend this shade a lot because it fits almost anywhere, irrespective of the decor.

The shade is a neutral color that gives off a warm feeling. This has a green undertone and it is best paired with pink or red.

Pewter by Benjamin Moore:

Pewter is pewter. It is a steely light gray color with a blue undertone. Beautiful and soft. Its LRV is 33.

Light pewter:

This is a warm neutral color. It’s lighter than the reverse pewter, with the LRV of 68. It has a grayer undertone than beige. If your house doesn’t get plenty of sunlight and you need the place to be brighter, this is your color.

Antique pewter:

This is a warm, beautiful gray green paint color with a beige undertone. It’s best for rooms with a generous amount of sunlight like the office, bathrooms, or cabinetry. It has an LRV of 24.15.

Vintage pewter:

Vintage pewter has beige and soft gray undertones with an LRV of 34.5.

Pewter tankard:

This is warm greige color paint, but it isn’t in the taupe color family. Although it shows depth, it’s dark and not suitable for rooms with low sunlight. Its LRV is 33.66.

Pewter green:

Pewter green is dark but bold, with a gray undertone. It expresses masculinity so that you can use it for your kitchen cabinets or a masculine office. It’s a dark and moody color.

Note: When using dark or slightly dark colors to paint, pair them with lighter colors that fit. Before painting, check the decor and other things in the room to see if it will blend.

You also need to be very creative or employ the services of an interior decorator, so you can know what color of pewter or charcoal paint to use in different parts of the house such as the office, library, rooms, kitchen, bathroom, etc.

GAF Timberline HD Shingles Color

GAF Timberline HD shingles come in various colors.

Weathered wood:

This neutral color blends with a dark or light-colored home.


This is a traditional shingles color of GAF. It is one of the best and safest when it comes to painting roofs.

It never gets old, fits almost every roof, and is the best choice if you’re unsure what to pick.

Pewter gray:

Pewter is as old as the Egyptian period and has been widely used since then.

Biscayne blue:

This Timberline HD color is designed to blend with blue shutters and light-colored vinyl siding.


Pewter gray and charcoal are both great colors for painting. However, they are perfect for different circumstances.

Pewter gray is a lighter color than charcoal and would be adequate for homes without plenty of sunlight. Pewter gray can give expression to a dark room. Pewter gray is warm, soft, and charming.

Charcoal, on the other hand, is dark, bold, and mysterious. It would be more fitting for a room with plenty of sunlight.

Both colors come in different shades and blends. Knowing what’s appropriate for you is essential to get the best result. When in doubt, contact an interior decorator.

Similar Posts:

About the author

I have always been a shopaholic. A lot of times my questions went unanswered when it came to retail questions, so I started Talk Radio News. - Caitlyn Johnson

Leave a Comment