Chairman Obey: A rising tide has raised only all yachts

by Christina Lovato, University of New Mexico-Talk Radio News Service

“Loosely speaking, rich dumb kids are more likely to make it through college than poor smart kids, and that’s telling you that we are a society in which whatever we may like to imagine we are not a society that has anything like equality of opportunity,” said Paul Krugman, a Professor of economics and international affairs at Princeton University and Nobel Prize-winner.

Today at a House Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health, and Human Services hearing, witnesses expressed their thoughts on the economy, healthcare and inequality. Krugman said that one major reason why a growing economy has failed to deliver to ordinary Americans is because of inequality. “Many of the gains in income went to a small minority of very well-off people, with most workers seeing little rise in real wage,” he said. Krugman said that the secondary reason for the failure of economic growth is the dysfunctional health care system. “We are unique among advanced countries in not having some form of universal coverage, yet we spend far more to cover 85 percent of our population than our counterparts spend to cover everyone, with no evidence that we receive correspondingly better care,” Krugman said.

Keith Hall, the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, had something different to say about healthcare. Hall said that since the start of the recession in December 2007, 4.4. million payroll jobs have been lost, and the unemployment rate has increased from 4.9 to 8.1 percent. But Hall said “employment has grown only in healthcare, private education, and government.”

“We first need to measure the stimulus package against the current needs of the economy…. The package as it now stands is mitigating. It’s not even enough to prevent us from having a very severe recession…. If we respond to concern about the size of the package by scaling back other government spending we’re undoing the effects of the stimulus package, making it even more inadequate,” concluded Krugman.

Chairman David R. Obey (D-Wis.) concluded the hearing by stating that he believes that we can strengthen the safety net for those who aren’t doing well in the economy through actions like universal healthcare and pension protection. “The problem is that it has been said by others in the past, at some times in our recent history it appears that a rising tide has raised only all yachts.”