Comments on: Interview with John McCardell, founder of the Amethyst Initiative http://talkradionews.com/2008/08/interview-with-john-mccardell-founder-of-the-amethyst-initiative/ The Talk Radio News Service is the only information news service dedicated to serving the talk radio community. Sun, 22 Nov 2009 13:19:19 -0800 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: Roy http://talkradionews.com/2008/08/interview-with-john-mccardell-founder-of-the-amethyst-initiative/comment-page-1/#comment-14636 Roy Thu, 21 Aug 2008 13:09:25 +0000 http://talkradionews.com/?p=20419#comment-14636 If no one is willing to enforce the laws and rules then it dosen't matter what they are or what the drinking age is. If no one is willing to enforce the laws and rules then it dosen’t matter what they are or what the drinking age is.

]]> By: S. Dawn Jones http://talkradionews.com/2008/08/interview-with-john-mccardell-founder-of-the-amethyst-initiative/comment-page-1/#comment-14538 S. Dawn Jones Wed, 20 Aug 2008 18:08:24 +0000 http://talkradionews.com/?p=20419#comment-14538 Don: The card idea is a bit odd, but perhaps instead of making the government act as our parents, the parents should do that? Roy: The most likely flaw with this plan that sticks out to me, is the REASON for trying to get the age dropped to 18 as opposed to 21. You say that it may be as simple as colleges enforcing their own rules, but in today's society where no one wants to be the enforcer, good luck with that. Don: The card idea is a bit odd, but perhaps instead of making the government act as our parents, the parents should do that?

Roy: The most likely flaw with this plan that sticks out to me, is the REASON for trying to get the age dropped to 18 as opposed to 21. You say that it may be as simple as colleges enforcing their own rules, but in today’s society where no one wants to be the enforcer, good luck with that.

]]> By: Roy http://talkradionews.com/2008/08/interview-with-john-mccardell-founder-of-the-amethyst-initiative/comment-page-1/#comment-14531 Roy Wed, 20 Aug 2008 16:39:09 +0000 http://talkradionews.com/?p=20419#comment-14531 It may be as simple as adults abiding by the laws in place and colleges enforcing their own rules. It may be as simple as adults abiding by the laws in place and colleges enforcing their own rules.

]]> By: Don http://talkradionews.com/2008/08/interview-with-john-mccardell-founder-of-the-amethyst-initiative/comment-page-1/#comment-14477 Don Wed, 20 Aug 2008 03:41:10 +0000 http://talkradionews.com/?p=20419#comment-14477 Monitor Drinking to Teach Moderate Drinking I have commented on this subject a few times on NPR radio when the Dean from a Vermont college (I believe he was from Middlebury College) approached this subject a few years ago. I believe that the best way to handle the lowering of the drinking age would be to place some restrictions on the young adults starting at the age of 18 to to perhaps 24 years of age. Perhaps limiting consumption of a 1 liter bottle of either beer or wine, not both, on a daily basis via use of a monthly issued punch card at a state or local government agency or by a liquor store itself could be a possibility. It may sound a little complicated and/or unnecessary but protection to abuse is important. Other means of monitoring are open but a method to limit access and stress its importance can be a teaching aid to young adults. Kegs of beer and hard liquor would not be accessible to age group that venerable to abuse. the daily limit to beer and wine could be change to perhaps a daily six pack of beer and/or daily bottle of wine at the age of 20 or 21 while maintaining a restriction to kegs and hard liquor until the age of 23, 24 or 25. Most people of this age are out of the colleges and/or of an age where they are more mature thus limiting the contact with the younger less mature college students and being more mature, would understand the perils of over indulgence better than an 18, 19 or 20 year old. A young person joining the military and willing to lay down their lives for our freedom and security should be exempt from all restrictions and able to drink at their peril! Monitor Drinking to Teach Moderate Drinking

I have commented on this subject a few times on NPR radio when the Dean from a Vermont college (I believe he was from Middlebury College) approached this subject a few years ago.

I believe that the best way to handle the lowering of the drinking age would be to place some restrictions on the young adults starting at the age of 18 to to perhaps 24 years of age. Perhaps limiting consumption of a 1 liter bottle of either beer or wine, not both, on a daily basis via use of a monthly issued punch card at a state or local government agency or by a liquor store itself could be a possibility. It may sound a little complicated and/or unnecessary but protection to abuse is important. Other means of monitoring are open but a method to limit access and stress its importance can be a teaching aid to young adults. Kegs of beer and hard liquor would not be accessible to age group that venerable to abuse. the daily limit to beer and wine could be change to perhaps a daily six pack of beer and/or daily bottle of wine at the age of 20 or 21 while maintaining a restriction to kegs and hard liquor until the age of 23, 24 or 25. Most people of this age are out of the colleges and/or of an age where they are more mature thus limiting the contact with the younger less mature college students and being more mature, would understand the perils of over indulgence better than an 18, 19 or 20 year old.

A young person joining the military and willing to lay down their lives for our freedom and security should be exempt from all restrictions and able to drink at their peril!

]]>